Exhibit Guide Navigation

Oratio Grassi, De tribus cometis anni MDCXVIII (Rome, 1619)

On the Three Comets of 1618

In 1618, three comets appeared, visible to the unaided eye. These were the first comets to be observed with the telescope. 

Grassi was the leading astronomer in Rome and a professor at the Rome College (Collegio Romano). As a Jesuit, Grassi was charged with teaching nothing in science contrary to Aristotle, who said that comets were vapors located beneath the Moon. Yet Grassi’s analysis demonstrated that these comets moved beyond the Moon!

This book therefore represents an interesting story: the leading Jesuit astronomer in Rome openly published an account of three well-known comets that was explicitly contrary to Aristotle. One might think that Galileo, whom Grassi admired, would have cheered him on. Yet in making this argument, Grassi unwittingly opened an episode that became known as the “controversy of the comets.” Tellingly, Galileo had been ill during 1618 and was not able to observe the comets himself.

Despite their avowed allegiance to Aristotle, Jesuits were more receptive than scholastics to heavenly comets, sunspots, new stars, fluid orbs, the corruptibility of the heavens and various non-Ptolemaic geocentric systems (see Introduction to the Jesuits). 

Vigorous Jesuit participation in the mathematical sciences, consisting of sustained investigations in optics, geodesy, astronomy and cosmology, make it possible to regard the Jesuits as one of the earliest scientific societies.

Galileo's World Exhibition Location

Source: History of Science Collections

Section: Controversy

Section Number: 2

Object Number: 26

Subject Area(s): Astronomy, Religious Studies

Time Period: 17th Century

Region(s): Italy

Click any Image for a larger version

Exhibit Gallery OERs

Phases of Venus: Riccioli, New Almagest

Phases of Venus-Riccioli

The phases of Venus were an item of discussion in early modern Europe as scientists sought to determine whether it was evidence of the heliocentric system. Yet among the scientists it was anything but conclusive that this evidence proved the sun-centered universe. Learn more in this learning leaflet.


Six Cosmological Systems: Phases of Venus

Kircher-Cosmological Systems-Venus

It is often thought that Galileo's discovery of the phases of venus demonstrated the contested heliocentric model of the universe. However, such an understanding is overly simplistic of the early modern account of astronomy. Use this learning leaflet to learn more.


Elisabeth Hevelius: Observational Astronomer

Elisabeth Hevelius Learning Leaflet

How does the Sextant symbolize the person who worked on the famed Hevelius star catalog and star atlas throughout its production, from observation to publication? 

Elisabeth Hevelius, wife of Johann Hevelius, was an astronomer in her own right. They worked together in the observatory of their Gdansk home to measure angular widths and distances with a great sextant, which required two observers at a time. The Sextant was among the new constellations they proposed in Uranographia (1690), the most detailed and influential celestial atlas of the 17th century. The Uranographia contains 54 beautiful double page engraved plates of 73 constellations, and 2 oversized folding plates of planispheres.